11 Best Mystery Puzzle Games to Challenge Your Mind

Discover the best mystery puzzle to ignite your curiosity and challenge your mind. Unravel secrets and engage with captivating twists today.
11 Best Mystery Puzzle Games to Challenge Your Mind

Top Quick Picks For You

Best Bang for Your Buck

Bepuzzled Classic Mystery Puzzle

Bepuzzled Classic Mystery Puzzle

The Bepuzzled Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - Sherlock Holmes offers great value with engaging gameplay and quality, making it an excellent choice for those seeking a budget-friendly yet entertaining experience.

Best for Mystery Lovers

Murder Mystery Party

Murder Mystery Party

The Murder Mystery Party | Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle, Death on The Istanbul Express uniquely combines storytelling with puzzle-solving, making it a must-have for mystery lovers looking for an immersive experience.

Best for Party Games

Ravensburger Escape Puzzle

Ravensburger Escape Puzzle

The Ravensburger 759-Piece Escape Puzzle - The Witches' Kitchen is ideal for parties, promoting collective problem-solving and shared enjoyment, which makes it perfect for group gatherings.

Best for Visual Artists

Magic Puzzle Company

Magic Puzzle Company

The Mystic Maze jigsaw puzzle features original artwork with intricate details, making it an exceptional choice for visual artists who appreciate beauty and complexity in their puzzles.

Best Mystery Puzzle

In a world brimming with toys that spark creativity and curiosity, the allure of a mystery puzzle captures the imagination like nothing else. These captivating challenges weave together an intricate tapestry of clues and surprises, inviting both young adventurers and seasoned sleuths to unlock the secrets hidden within. Join us as we uncover the best mystery puzzles that promise to turn any playtime into an exhilarating quest for discovery.

Best Bang for Your Buck: Bepuzzled Classic Mystery Puzzle

Bepuzzled Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - Sherlock Holmes, 1000
Highlights
Engaging mystery storyline
Well-fitting pieces
Creative puzzle design

When it comes to a thrilling evening of puzzling, the Bepuzzled Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - Sherlock Holmes truly earns its title as our "Best Bang for Your Buck." This isn't just any jigsaw puzzle; it’s an immersive adventure waiting to unfold .

Dive into the intriguing mystery of Death at Stoke Moran Manor House and assemble 1,000 well-fitting pieces that measure 23'' x 29'' .

As you piece together the captivating imagery, hidden clues emerge to keep your sleuthing spirit engaged .

Although some may find the complex story a bit challenging, the experience is undeniably rewarding .

This puzzle offers a unique blend of fun and mystery that we believe every puzzler aged 15 and over will enjoy!

Be sure to also check out the best finger puppets for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Bepuzzled Classic Mystery Puzzle on Amazon

Best for Mystery Lovers: Murder Mystery Party

Murder Mystery Party | Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle, Death on The Istanbul Express, 1,000 Piece Jigsaw Puzzle, Orange
Highlights
Engaging mystery experience
Challenging and fun
Quality puzzle pieces

In our quest for the finest in mystery puzzles, we found the Murder Mystery Party | Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle, Death on The Istanbul Express to be an outstanding choice for mystery enthusiasts .

This engaging puzzle isn’t just about assembling pieces; it’s an immersive story waiting to unfold .

With 1,000 intricately designed pieces, solvers will find hidden clues that lead to the shocking reveal .

The included booklet adds depth, allowing us to piece together the mystery in a truly unique way .

Just remember, the image doesn’t match the package—embrace the challenge and prepare for an unforgettable puzzle experience!

Be sure to also check out the best puzzle advent calendar for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Murder Mystery Party on Amazon

Best for Party Games: Ravensburger Escape Puzzle

Ravensburger 759-Piece Escape Puzzle - The Witches' Kitchen | Engaging Jigsaw for Kids & Adults | Exciting Escape Room Experience | Ideal for Family Game Nights | FSC-Certified Materials
Highlights
Engaging and challenging gameplay
High-quality materials used
Ideal for social activities

We absolutely adore the Ravensburger 759-Piece Escape Puzzle - The Witches' Kitchen !

It’s been crowned our pick for "Best for Party Games" and for good reason .

This thrilling 759-piece puzzle turns a typical game night into an immersive experience filled with engaging riddles and captivating storytelling .

Crafted from high-quality, sustainable materials, it combines eco-friendly fun with a challenge that keeps everyone on their toes .

The twist ?

The final image differs slightly from the box art, prompting us to sharpen our attention to detail .

It's perfect for gatherings, ensuring moments of laughter and shared victory as friends tackle the puzzles together!

Be sure to also check out the best teeter totters for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Ravensburger Escape Puzzle on Amazon

Best for Visual Artists: Magic Puzzle Company

The Mystic Maze • 1000-Piece Jigsaw Puzzle from The Magic Puzzle Company • Series One
Highlights
Beautiful artwork
Challenging and engaging
Includes two poster guides

The Mystic Maze jigsaw puzzle is a feast for the eyes and mind !

Bursting with original artwork, this 1000-piece challenge mesmerizes with intricate details and over 50 hidden easter eggs just waiting to be uncovered .

What sets it apart ?

A mind-bending magical twist ending that employs optical illusions to surprise you as you finish .

As a delightful bonus, it comes with not one, but TWO art posters so friends can join the fun .

While some puzzles might arrive with a missing piece or two, the experience and beauty of the Mystic Maze is truly captivating .

Let the adventure begin!

Be sure to also check out the best toy castles for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Magic Puzzle Company on Amazon

Murder Most Puzzling

Murder Most Puzzling: The Missing Will 500-Piece Puzzle
Highlights
Unique mystery element
Moderate difficulty
Nostalgic appeal

Prepare for a jigsaw experience like no other with this mystery puzzle that adds an exhilarating twist to classic puzzling !

We adore how the full image remains a secret until you've pieced it together, making it an enticing challenge for both seasoned puzzlers and mystery buffs alike .

Nostalgia fans will appreciate the homage to beloved creators like Agatha Christie, while the stunning, richly illustrated finale is a visual treat that adds charm to any space .

Though the packaging might be prone to a little wear and tear, the fun and intrigue are what truly matter .

Get ready to unravel the mystery!

Be sure to also check out the best water table for preschoolers for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Murder Most Puzzling on Amazon

Murder Mystery Party

Bepuzzled Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle - Foul Play & Cabernet, Red
Highlights
Engaging storyline
Challenging puzzle assembly
Fun for families

We’re excited to share our thoughts on the Foul Play and Cabernet mystery puzzle from BePuzzled !

This isn’t just any jigsaw puzzle – it’s a thrilling murder mystery waiting for you to unravel .

With 1,000 pieces to assemble, the challenge is not just in completing the picture but in piecing together clues from the included short story booklet .

The final reveal is a clever twist, using a mirror for the ultimate clue !

Though there’s no picture guidance, the engaging storyline makes it perfect for puzzle enthusiasts aged 15 and up .

If you're ready for a brain-teasing adventure, this is the puzzle for you!

Be sure to also check out the best puzzle board with drawers for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Murder Mystery Party on Amazon

iDventure Cluebox Mystery Puzzle

iDventure Cluebox - Schroedingers Cat - Escape Room Game - Puzzle Box - 3D Wooden Puzzle for Adults - Treasure Box - Gift Box - Brain Teaser - Birthday Gift Gadget for Men and Women - Money Box
Highlights
Intricate craftsmanship
Challenging gameplay
Reusable for new players

The iDventure Cluebox Schrödinger’s Cat is a delightful escape room experience packed into an elegantly crafted wooden puzzle box .

With its intricate craftsmanship and captivating logic challenges, we found ourselves thoroughly immersed, attempting to unlock the mysteries within .

The blend of suspenseful storytelling and engaging gameplay kept us on our toes, as we worked to save Schrödinger’s cat .

The reusable design lets you share the adventure with new players, but do handle it with care, as the pieces can be delicate .

This 3D puzzle is not just a game—it's a stylish accessory and a unique gift, making it a standout choice for puzzle enthusiasts!

Be sure to also check out the best puzzle roll up mat for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for iDventure Cluebox on Amazon

BePuzzled

BePuzzled | Unravel the Mystery, Grounds for Murder - Classic Mystery 1000 pc. Jigsaw Puzzle for Thrill-Seekers and Puzzle Enthusiasts!
Highlights
Engaging murder mystery theme
Challenging without reference image
Collectible with multiple titles

If you're ready to dive into a thrilling whodunit, the Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzle series is a perfect pick for any avid puzzler aged 15 and up !

With each 1,000-piece challenge, you won’t just be piecing together an image; you'll be unraveling a murder mystery! As you assemble the puzzle, hidden clues await to aid in solving the crime, making every piece a part of the action .

Plus, don’t forget to utilize that mirror trick to ultimately reveal the murderer—it adds an exciting twist !

With various titles in the series, there's a mystery waiting for everyone .

Get puzzling!

Be sure to also check out the best monster jam toys for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for BePuzzled on Amazon

Murder Mystery Party Puzzle

Bepuzzled Classic Mystery Recipe For Murder Jigsaw Puzzle by University Games |Comes with Murder Mystery and Jigsaw Puzzle | 1,000 Piece Jigsaw | For Ages 12 Years and Up
Highlights
Engaging mystery concept
No image for challenge
Hours of fun

We absolutely adore the Classic Mystery Jigsaw Puzzles !

More than just a standard puzzle, it immerses you in a thrilling murder mystery, adding an extra layer of excitement .

As you piece together the 1,000 pieces, you’ll discover hidden clues that unravel a chilling story of a dinner party gone wrong .

While the puzzle image doesn’t match the packaging, this twist adds to the challenge .

Just remember, you’ll need to read the included booklet first to truly appreciate the mystery .

With hours of engaging fun, this puzzle is perfect for those aged 15 and up who crave a delightful brain teaser!

Be sure to also check out the best glider plane toy for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Murder Mystery Party Puzzle on Amazon

Awakened Artifacts Mystery Puzzle

The Awakened Artifacts • 1000-Piece Jigsaw Puzzle from The Magic Puzzle Company • Series Four
Highlights
Unique magic ending
High-quality artwork
Engaging and challenging

We’re thrilled to introduce The Awakened Artifacts, a captivating 1000-piece jigsaw puzzle that transforms the classic puzzle experience into a magical adventure .

With exquisite artwork and over 50 hidden easter eggs, each piece invites you to uncover intricate details as you piece together the vibrant tapestry .

The stunning visual illusions create an amazing surprise once completed, ensuring it’s unlike any puzzle you've tackled before .

We appreciate the commitment to quality—with no puzzle dust or single-use plastic—making it a guilt-free addition to your collection .

Perfect for puzzle enthusiasts aged 15 and up, it's an engaging challenge that promises hours of fun!

Be sure to also check out the best toy guns for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Awakened Artifacts on Amazon

Magic Puzzle Company

Big Rock City • 1000-Piece Jigsaw Puzzle from The Magic Puzzle Company • Series Four
Highlights
Unique magic twist ending
Beautiful, detailed artwork
No puzzle dust

At the top of our list is the mesmerizing Big Rock City puzzle !

This 1000-piece marvel invites you to dive deep into its stunning artwork, bursting with over 50 hidden easter eggs waiting to be uncovered .

We absolutely love the mind-blowing twist at the end—think magic and visual illusions intertwined !

Plus, you can forget about that annoying puzzle dust, as this beauty arrives clean and crisp .

While some pieces may stray from the standard size and a few boxes might show wear, the overall experience is simply enchanting .

Grab a friend and enjoy the included art posters for a delightful journey!

Be sure to also check out the best friend plush for more options! Also, here is the price history so you know exactly when to buy!

Price history for Magic Puzzle Company on Amazon

🎯 Popular Posts

Never Miss A Post!

Sign up for free to Tiny Toy Trove and be the first to get notified about updates.

Never Miss A Post! 🎉
Subscribe to our newsletter and get the latest deals and news
  • 01Get discounts on products and memberships
  • 02Get notified about new posts, reviews and updates
subsc